JOIN US MAY 20-21 FOR RESTORE CONFERENCE

Mary
DeMuth

Scot
McKnight

Screenshot 2023-01-13 at 1.50.18 PM

Naghmeh
Panahi

Reporting the Truth.
Restoring the Church.

In Southern California, Black Churches Are Using Their Land to Build Housing For Homeless People

By Alejandra Molina
A rendering of the permanent supportive housing structure Heavenly Vision Church plans to build. (Photo Credit- SDS Capital Group)

As Southern California’s housing crisis continues to fuel homelessness across the region, a number of churches, particularly Black congregations, are stepping up to build affordable housing on their church land.

And they’re banding together to send a clear message to developers: They will not be taken advantage of.

As the homeless population is estimated to hover above 66,000 people in Los Angeles County alone, there are thousands of acres of church land across California that can be used to develop housing. Pastors—some who have inherited debt or years of deferred maintenance and whose church memberships may not be as large as in years past—recognize this opportunity, but may lack the resources or knowledge to cut housing deals that would not only help the most needy, but also help their church communities remain in their neighborhoods.

For years, the Rev. John Cager, pastor of Ward African Methodist Episcopal Church in South Los Angeles, has seen how developers would run “roughshod over the churches,” buying their properties for housing while offering sometimes as low as 2% of the revenues in exchange.

What often happens is many of these churches—considered “land rich and cash poor”—would get a check, very often under market rate, “and then they would be out,” Cager said.

Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “Even If He Doesn’t: What We Believe about God When Life Doesn’t Make Sense” by Kristen LaValley. To donate, click here.

“Many times when churches sell, that breaks up the congregation. They don’t have the organizational wealth to stay together, the money kind of evaporates and what you basically have is the loss of the church community,” said Cager, whose church is 115 years old.

The Rev. John Cager (Photo Credit: John Cager)

 

That’s a main reason Cager in 2017 helped create the Faith Community Coalition, a network of pastors that seeks to find better opportunities for faith leaders who may feel the need to sell when they’re in a position of declining revenue. Ultimately, the coalition aims for churches to work with developers who are willing to enter into full partnerships with parishes, evenly splitting the revenues, and paving the way for the houses of worship to eventually own the properties.

So far, the alliance has more than 200 member churches, most of them African American. A number of Latino evangelical churches are also part of the network. Cager said it’s no coincidence many of his fellow Black and Latino pastors were being bombarded by people who wanted to buy their churches.

“Black and Latinx communities, communities of color, have historically been preyed upon,” he said.

While the coalition started in South LA, churches in the network are located across the five counties that make up Southern California. About 40 churches in the coalition are actively seeking to build housing developments on their land. But not just any housing.

Cager said the coalition strives to build housing for those who are unhoused.

“The operating ethos of the coalition is that we want to do housing and do development as a ministry,” Cager said. “We believe in the gospel of Jesus Christ.

“We have a heart for serving the least, the lost, the left out, and the left behind. So it is the heart of our churches and our church members that we have an eye for the unhoused, and we have an eye for seniors, for transition-aged youth. Those who have the most issues finding a safe secure housing,” he added.

Harvest Tabernacle Bible Church (Photo Credit: Alejandra Molina)

A number of churches are fulfilling this mission through a partnership with RMG Housing, a private developer, that with the help of a more than $100 million private-equity impact fund and without government funding, is expected to finance 30 permanent supportive housing projects. Currently, about seven of the 15 projects are planned to take place on church land.

The housing units will be constructed for under $200,000 each, said Deborah La Franchi, president and chief executive of impact-fund manager SDS Capital Group. Revenue to cover the debt will come from sources such as the federal Section 8 housing program that will be used to pay the rent.

La Franchi said she expects the SDS Supportive Housing Fund to reach $150 million.

Most of the churches SDS Capital Group has been working with are African Methodist Episcopal and African American Baptist churches that are pillars in their communities, La Franchi said.

To La Franchi, this collaboration makes sense.

“This is a way for the churches to achieve their mission, help to revitalize their community (and) help transform the lives of these individuals that will be housed in their property,” La Franchi said. “At the same time the church is benefiting of the cash flow of the project, which is very helpful to many of them.”

The proposed housing to be built on Harvest Tabernacle Bible Church’s current site. (Photo Credit: SDS Capital Group)

For some churches, this may mean razing their entire properties and using the resources to move to a new location that’s scaled to the current size of their congregation, La Franchi said.

Tim Roth, a developer for RMG Housing, said he didn’t specifically seek to do business with churches. He was introduced to pastor Cager through others in the real estate business. What Roth was seeing across LA and other cities were zoning changes that, whether intentionally or not, devalued church properties. This would lead to a church not being as valuable as the land across the street, Roth said.

“That was alarming to me,” he said.

Roth, who was raised Catholic and who described himself as religious, said that instead of buying church land, RMG has opted to engage in 99-year ground leases with the churches. In turn, the churches can participate in the cash flow of the project, on equal terms with RMG. The houses of faith can either “finance us out, or buy us out,” Roth said.

“They can own it completely if that was in their best interest or they can simply maintain use and have us as partners all the way through,” Roth added. “That was the important thing, that we can be a good partner and, in time, they can own it all.”

“It’s all about fellowship, isn’t it?” he said.

At Heavenly Vision Church in South Los Angeles, which has been at its current location since 1969, church members are getting ready to break ground on a 54-unit permanent supportive housing structure that will be built on the church’s school lot after the school is demolished. The project will be funded through SDS Capital Group. 

Heavenly Vision Church (Photo Credit: Google Maps)

Bishop James Taylor, pastor of Heavenly Vision Church, eventually foresees the church building also being leveled to build more housing. Taylor said the congregation is open to doing church digitally or in a different location to make way for housing for those who need it most.

“We want to make sure we’re meeting that need more than meeting our own comfort,” Taylor said. “Giving somebody a place to stay is more important for us than having a comfortable place to worship in.

“It should be the church’s desire to leverage the land and the property they own to meet the need,” he added.

Harvest Tabernacle Bible Church around the Southeast Los Angeles area is another congregation that will be building units through RMG Housing and with SDS funding.

The church — adjacent to Pueblo del Rio, one of the oldest public housing complexes in LA — will be demolished to make way for affordable housing accommodating about 150 families.

Senior Pastor Donald Cook said the congregation, which his father established in 1976, has about 125 members and will relocate to a new space nearby.

“We still want our hand in the community,” Cook said. “We will not abandon the people. We will not leave.”

Alejandra MolinaAlejandra Molina is a national reporter for Religion News Service based in Los Angeles, California.

The Associated Press also contributed to this report.

SHARE THIS:

GET EMAIL UPDATES!

Keep in touch with Julie and get updates in your inbox!

Don’t worry we won’t spam you.

More to explore
discussion

20 Responses

  1. Churches/Pastors… PLEASE be discerning! PRAY and seek God’s voice in these “land/church” matters. From experience, the developer/ buyers Do not have your interest at heart.
    What APPEARS to be is not always WHAT IT IS TO BE.

  2. What a great potential New Testament solution to the problem!

    While there are many potential pitfalls to the plan, there have also been plenty of pitfalls in churches buying land, padded pews, and air conditioning to lull the flock into complacency and apathy!

    1. New Testament solution? Where in the New Testament did the church build housing for those outside of the church? Individuals sold property, and gave the proceeds to the apostles, for the purpose of caring for the poor within the body of Christ. The church’s mission has never been to be a social service agency.

      1. You don’t think we should care for the poor unless they are part of the church? Really?

        “Is not this the kind of fasting I have chosen:
        to loose the chains of injustice
        and untie the cords of the yoke,
        to set the oppressed free
        and break every yoke?
        Is it not to share your food with the hungry
        and to provide the poor wanderer with shelter—
        when you see the naked, to clothe them,
        and not to turn away from your own flesh and blood?
        Then your light will break forth like the dawn,
        and your healing will quickly appear;
        then your righteousness will go before you,
        and the glory of the Lord will be your rear guard.
        Then you will call, and the Lord will answer;
        you will cry for help, and he will say: Here am I.

  3. Their hearts may be in the right place, but their thought process is not. Homelessness is not about a lack of housing. Homelessness is about addiction and mental illness. Until you address those things, you can build all the housing you want. It won’t decrease homelessness, and before long it will follow in the way of all housing “projects”.

    1. There always has to be someone who just doesn’t get it. I believe somewhere in the Gospels Jesus said “I was sick and you visited me I was hungry and you gave me something to eat I was naked and you clothed me I was in jail and you helped me. And when you did these things to the least of these my brothers, you did this to me”. . . . have some compassion and pity for those in need. May our Lord Jesus bless these dear African-American brothers and sisters who are helping those who have such a desperate need, again may God bless them!! Mr. Harr must be related to Ebenezer Scrooge, can I get an amen!?!

    2. In CA, one can have “real” jobs and still be homeless because they don’t pay nearly enough for the inflated housing costs.

    3. Actually Jim, the city of Helsinki built housing for the homeless because they found that access to stable housing was essential for those with mental illness and addictions; wthout it, they continued to spiral downward. But with housing came access to onsite social services and basic medical services, which led to an increase in mental health treatment and successful rehabilitation. Imagine what could happen when you include the presence and prayers of God’s people!

  4. I love this! This is an answer to my prayers that the Ekklesia can reclaim our God given responsibility to the poor that we have by and large abdicated to the gov’t… may this be so many times over… I would think that each of the sites includes access to available resources in the community via public transportation for those with addictions and mental illnesses and other health concerns… and those involved have worked through many of the numerous dynamics that are unique to the marginalized in our communities, recognizing there is always more to learn…

    keep praying Church! God is on the move!

  5. As Southern California’s housing crisis continues to fuel homelessness across the region,

    Totally false. Drug addiction fuels the crisis. 90% are on hard drugs and prefer to live on the streets where drugs are available. Most of the drug addicts are from out-of-state.

    Ultimately, the coalition aims for churches to work with developers who are willing to enter into full partnerships with parishes, evenly splitting the revenues, and paving the way for the houses of worship to eventually own the properties.

    The “revenues” come directly from the government and are quite lucrative. In other words, rather than let the developers become the slum lords collecting housing vouchers for vagrant housing, they’ve gotten into the business themselves. Woe to the neighbors who will deal with the increase in crime and filth.

    This will likely provoke a backlash against the churches.

    Watch “Seattle is Dying” and report some legitimate solutions like mandatory drug rehab, please.

      1. How do you know what you’re reading is true, including the premise of this entire article that high housing prices are causing homelessness?

          1. Yes, and just moved from an area with a homeless encampment that made international news and have much experience with the problem.

            There, I’ve answered one of your questions. How about mine?

  6. I have very mixed feelings about this. On one hand, the idea of helping others by converting underutilized church buildings to housing makes a lot a sense. On the other hand, churches in those neighborhoods are often lighthouses showing the way to Jesus.

  7. This is what living out the Christian life looks like – for God’s glory, His kingdom, and His people!

Leave a Reply

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people register before they begin commenting. This means no anonymous comments will be allowed. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
 
MOST RECENT Articles
MOST popular articles
en_USEnglish

Donate

Hi. We see this is the third article this month you’ve found worth reading. Great! Would you consider making a tax-deductible donation to help our journalists continue to report the truth and restore the church?

Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “The Atlas Factor: Shifting Leadership Onto the Shoulders of Jesus” by Lance Ford.