JOIN US MAY 20-21 FOR RESTORE CONFERENCE

Mary
DeMuth

Scot
McKnight

Screenshot 2023-01-13 at 1.50.18 PM

Naghmeh
Panahi

Reporting the Truth.
Restoring the Church.

Controversial Florida Baptist Pastor Resigns After Church’s ECFA Suspension

By Josh Shepherd
james welch FBFTL
James Welch preaches at First Baptist Fort Lauderdale in southeast Florida. (Photo via Facebook)

The lead pastor of a prominent south Florida church has resigned, following a turbulent four-year tenure marked by allegations of lack of financial transparency and hundreds of members expelled or deciding to leave the church. 

On Wednesday, First Baptist Fort Lauderdale (FBFTL) announced that James Welch, who had been hired in February 2019, has departed. “(He) has resigned as lead pastor this week to pursue other interests,” said the statement from the church’s Trustee Board and Deacon Body. They added that a “plan of action to search for a new lead pastor” will be announced Sunday.

Affiliated with the Southern Baptist Convention, the historic church owns a seven-acre downtown campus reportedly worth over $120 million, including a main sanctuary that can seat over 2,500 people. However, in recent years, weekly attendance at FBFTL has dwindled to fewer than 200 people, according to multiple sources. 

Welch, who marked his fourth anniversary with the church two weeks ago, commented via Instagram on Thursday about his departure. “Life is full of seasons. Some come to end sooner than expected,” he wrote. He also described his pastorate at FBFTL as “a season of stretching and learning.” 

The controversial pastor’s exit comes only days after Ministry Watch reported that the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA) has suspended the church. Many large churches and ministries use the ECFA as a “seal of approval” to reassure members of effective charitable giving. 

Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “Baptistland: A Memoir of Abuse, Betrayal, and Transformation” by Christa Brown. To donate, click here.

FBFTL
Downtown campus of First Baptist Fort Lauderdale (Photo: Google Street View)

A recently updated ECFA public report stated that FBFTL has been suspended as of October last year while “under review of compliance with Standard 4.” This standard of the ECFA concerns the church exercising proper “management and controls” to ensure compliance with “applicable laws and regulations.” 

In a statement to media, Steve Blount, executive director of ministry services at FBFTL, said: “We aren’t surprised by the review, given the sustained campaign of unsupported and unsubstantiated public criticism we have endured these last three years,”

Since 2020, more than 200 former FBFTL members have formed a group called Concerned Members of First Baptist Fort Lauderdale. Their spokesman, Brian Keno, said they are pressing for “transparency and accountability” following years of church mismanagement. 

“We’re trying to get our church to open their books and show us where the money went,” he said. “Why are we broke? As former members, we’re also trying to get our rights back that were stripped away from us.”

Under Welch’s leadership, reportedly more than 100 members have had their membership “terminated.” One of those members provided a letter he received, dated July 16, 2021. The letter stated the board had terminated his membership because his actions “contributed to discord within our church (and) encouraged divisions.”

In his Instagram post, Welch framed his departure from the church as pre-planned. “What a way to wrap it up, a message on the Holy Spirit, a full altar, and a baptism. I submitted my resignation the next day,” he wrote. He also encouraged prayer for the church as it begins a pastoral search process. 

However, on Sunday, Welch preached the third part of a four-part sermon series and did not allude to his departure. 

Holly Orr, part of the Concerned Members group, called his exit “sudden and abrupt.” She added: “There is more to this, and the congregation should know the truth.” 

The Roys Report (TRR) reached out to FBFTL for comment but did not hear back. 

james amy welch fbftl
On February 26, 2023, James and Amy Welch receive prayer from leaders of First Baptist Fort Lauderdale during a Sunday service celebrating their four-year tenure. (Photo via Facebook)

Questions around sale of church land

While it was not specified by the ECFA, the group’s review of First Baptist Fort Lauderdale may stem in part from questions surrounding a sale of church land last August.

Blount, who is also a church trustee, told a local newspaper in 2021: “The property is our most valuable asset and it’s not for sale.” Yet, within a year, the church sold a small parcel of its downtown property to the Naftali Group, a New York-based real estate development firm.

According to local news site Florida Bulldog, the congregation met on July 31 and voted to sell the parcel of land located at 501 NE 2nd St., which is across the street from the main church campus. However, the sale price and buyer’s identity were not disclosed to church members. 

Responding to criticism on August 19 last year, church leaders stated: “We cannot contractually disclose the price of the sale, but it was considerably higher than the appraised value.”

The Concerned Members group says this transaction confirms their claims of the lack of financial transparency. “We still don’t know the sale price of that lot which was owned by the church,” said Keno, who is a local business owner. 

“How can you do business like this in a congregational-led church?” 

Author of church bylaws files suit against church

Dissident members have raised other disputed issues. Welch reportedly had an annual salary of $250,000 during his tenure, which some Concerned Members deemed “excessive,” said Keno. 

During the first year of his pastorate, Welch canceled the church’s 36-year-running annual Christmas Pageant. While former members claim the elaborate show raised significant revenue, church leaders claimed in a statement that it was “a large financial burden.”

Those initial issues, in addition to the forced termination of members who questioned such moves, sparked the formation of the Concerned Members of FBFTL group. They found an ally in James Geiger, a former attorney and church member for over 50 years. “He wrote our church bylaws many, many years ago,” said Keno. 

FBFTL
First Baptist Fort Lauderdale (Photo via Facebook)

On June 22, 2021, Geiger and a few other longtime members filed a civil lawsuit to force arbitration between First Baptist Fort Lauderdale and the group of dissident members. 

Last May, Broward County Circuit Judge Jeffrey Levenson ordered the church to enter arbitration with the Concerned Members group. Ten months later, those meetings have not yet been initiated according to multiple sources. 

John Harris, a longtime member of FBFTL and a party with Geiger in the suit, provided a statement to TRR regarding the current stance of Concerned Members of FBFTL. 

“We are hopeful for a swift resolution including an opportunity to review our internal issues with the current FBFTL administrators,” he stated. “Otherwise, we will be forced to advance the quest in Court for clarification of the current order to compel arbitration, granted by the court.”

In its emailed statement on Wednesday, the church sought to reassure members. The church stated: “Be assured that the work and ministry of FBFTL, as directed by God’s Word, and illuminated by way of the Holy Spirit, will not be deterred.”

Email sent on March 8, 2023 to First Baptist Fort Lauderdale members

FBFTL

Freelance journalist Josh Shepherd writes on faith, culture, and public policy for several media outlets. He and his wife live in the Washington, D.C. area with their two children.

SHARE THIS:

GET EMAIL UPDATES!

Keep in touch with Julie and get updates in your inbox!

Don’t worry we won’t spam you.

More to explore
discussion

6 Responses

  1. ECFA. Good concept but some would say their track record is not so good on quick and comprehensive accountability.

    Bottom line. If your church says they are transparent from the pulpit but then obfuscates any legitimate, peaceful inquiries about finances or leadership structure, you have a BIG problem “behind the curtain.” Can’t tell you how many times we’ve seen this, the appearance of transparency but the destruction of anyone who thinks critically or asks important questions. Some leadership will protect their self interests at all costs.

    You then have to decide,

    A. “Can I come worship every week and stay oblivious to leadership issues so I won’t be distracted in my spiritual growth and can serve others effectively?” or

    B.”Would God not want me to enable bad leadership to behave badly (even criminally) hurting other people because of my passivity and self focus?”

    Either way, you have to pray about how to respond either as an agent of accountability or leaving quietly.

    Needed church reform continues.

  2. I wonder if it would be possible for church members to become vested with ownership rights regarding church assets? Members hand over so much time, energy, and money to churches, is it appropriate to receive something back when assets are sold off? Members could designate where they want returns to go: themselves, some other ministry, etc… Large properties, especially if they can be converted into something other than a church, can really gain in value over the course of a church’s life – it seems foolish to entrust a couple people at the top to make good choices with this money.

  3. What took them so long? How did they miss knowing the real him when they first interviewed him, later hired him, and then permitted him to unilaterally do so much with which they didn’t agree? In four years, the problems manifested NOT just last week! Did HE cancel the Christmas Pageant singlehandedly? I doubt it – unless this church was full of mindless sheep! How sad – or, more appropriately, how BAAAAD!!!

  4. Always weird when a pastor resigns abruptly and the note goes out from the board like an eulogy. A church that holds 2500 and has less than 200 membership attendance has a leadership issue. Add to the lack of transparency, looks like the church is fudging numbers or hiding that they are in the red. Lastly, wondering if the board was all aware of this and did nothing while evicting members from speaking up by “causing divisions.”

  5. I think I read somewhere else about another lack of transparency over the sale price of a piece of land, that did not end too well for the vendors. One of them, I think, was a lady with a name that means “Sapphire” (and should have been translated as such in all vernacular bibles).

  6. “…given the sustained campaign of unsupported and unsubstantiated public criticism we have endured these last three years.” If the claims made against Welch are unsupported and unsubstantiated, why did you remove hundreds from your midst? You could have opened the books and provided information to quell the mounting criticism. You didn’t obey a court order calling for arbitration even after 10 months passed. Those seeking to address and to rectify the collapse of confidence were willing to meet. Demanding that they had to repent of various issues first, violated the spirit of the Order. You were obliged to meet with all of them individually to try to work out differences. You don’t ban hundreds of congregants en masse over vague claims. Those folks didn’t suddenly decide to fabricate their concerns for nothing. They were your brothers and sisters. Why didn’t you hear them out?
    To get a more accurate picture of the man to whom you paid a million dollars, make a thorough examination of his past including his references to the “church” he pastored, and what happened to it when he joined you. There was some serious shenanigans going down over yonder before he got 250K a year from you. If you look very carefully, I believe you will find detailed facts you hadn’t considered upon hiring him.

Leave a Reply

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people register before they begin commenting. This means no anonymous comments will be allowed. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
 
MOST RECENT Articles
MOST popular articles
en_USEnglish