HBC Naples Interim Pastor States Cardinal Rule of Elders: “Never Share Dissension or Disagreement to the Church or Publicly”

By Julie Roys

Given that Harvest Bible Chapel is allowing its Naples campus to return to being an autonomous church, many have wondered why John Secrest, the founding pastor of that church who was fired by Harvest, is not being invited back. On Sunday, interim Pastor Russell Taylor gave the answer. Apparently, Secrest broke the cardinal rule of abusive church systems: never, under any circumstances, oppose church leadership to the larger church or to the public.

While explaining why Secrest had been fired and replaced by himself, Taylor said, “When elders are in disagreement about direction, it is always appropriate to table that issue and to continue to pray about that issue until consensus can be arrived at. So as a pastor, if I’m in disagreement with the elders, it’s appropriate for me to say, ‘Ok, this is where I’m at, this is my concern. I want us to continue to pray about this, and continue to walk through this, and we will entertain this later.’ But it is never open to me to be able to go outside of that eldership and share my dissension or disagreement to the church or publicly. That’s a basic, fundamental principle that governs eldership.”

“But it is never open to me to be able to go outside of that eldership and share my dissension or disagreement to the church or publicly. That’s a basic, fundamental principle that governs eldership.”

So according to Taylor, there is never a time when a pastor may break from elder authority–even if those elders are sinning and supporting sin, or as was the case in Naples, if the elders are capitulating to a sinning and controlling pastor who wants to remain in the pulpit when he’s clearly been disqualified. 

Biblically, the reasons for disqualifying an elder/pastor are things like failing to live “above reproach,” being “violent” instead of “gentle,” “arrogant,” “a lover of money,” etc . . . (1 Tim. 3; Titus 1) But in abusive systems, loyalty is premium. Forget 1 Timothy 5:20, where it says a sinning elder must be exposed publicly. Forget also Galatians 2 where we’re told that the apostle Paul publicly confronted his fellow apostle Peter for his hypocrisy of refusing to eat with the Gentiles. Instead, state your own rule, pretend it’s not yours, but God’s–and convince the congregation that submitting to your perverse rule is somehow godly.

This is precisely what’s happening in Naples. John Secrest’s “sin” is that he stood up to James MacDonald, a sinning pastor, and his complicit elder board. He refused to hand over his pulpit to a wolf who abused sheep. That should  make Secrest a hero. And if HBC Naples were governed by discerning men, he would be. But these men have shown their true colors by rejecting Secrest. Their loyalty is not to righteousness; it’s to James MacDonald and the kind of abusive system he created.

Give a gift of any amount to The Roys Report and receive a copy of “Have we lost our Head?: Reconnecting churches with Jesus” To donate, click here.

In addition to his comments Sunday, Taylor also condemned an email that was sent to the congregation on Sunday night, inviting them and Naples Elders Scott Stonebreaker and Fred Ananias to a neutral, moderated question and answer session with John Secrest. Spiritually abusive leaders hate open communication and always seek to control the narrative.

In an emailed response, Taylor labeled the invitation a “unauthorized communication,” and announced that no staff or leadership from HBC Naples would attend. He also told the congregation that official emails “will only come from a @harvestnaples.org domain.”

“John Secrest’s ‘sin’ is that he stood up to James MacDonald, a sinning pastor, and his complicit elder board . . . That should  make Secrest a hero. And if HBC Naples were governed by discerning men, he would be.”

These actions dispel any doubt about the nature of the leadership in Naples. Taylor, who was trained by Harvest in Chicago, is a man made in MacDonald’s image. He and his elders, who also were trained under MacDonald, will establish a church very much like their mother church. And if they continue to enforce their cardinal rule, they will suffer the same devastating consequences that Harvest in Chicago is suffering now. 

But they have a choice. They can repent of their wrong actions, fire Taylor, rehire Secrest, and then resign. Harvest Naples deserves a clean slate and these men, if they have any decency at all, should recognize that. 

The congregation at HBC Naples has a choice, as well. Abusive systems operate by deceiving the sheep. What Taylor said can sound spiritual, but it’s insidious. I encourage congregants to be like the Bereans mentioned in Acts 17. Like them, read your Bibles and see if what your leaders are saying is true. Don’t abide by their no-talk rules or their proposed blackouts from social media and blogs. Abusive leaders fear the truth and open communication. Godly leaders encourage it.

Below is the transcript and audio of Taylor’s comments Sunday; the email invitation to the Q&A meeting; and Taylor’s email condemning the Q&A invitation:

Transcript of Russell Taylor’s comments on Sunday:

. . . or can be communicated is unfortunately, uh, insufficient to satisfy all the questions. And sometimes you’ve have to make some statements that are just going to leave people wondering. And unfortunately, the hard thing about being a pastor, and the hard thing about being an elder is that you just can’t get to where everybody wants to get. And that’s so hard for you, because you want to know more. And it’s hard for the elders because sometimes they just have to live with the ambiguous criticism and some of that that comes from that. That’s a very difficult thing. So for that, that really can’t be remedied, entirely. 

Another part of that is just a little bit of protocol understanding within the context of elders. When elders are in disagreement about direction, it is always appropriate to table that issue and to continue to pray about that issue until consensus can be arrived at. So as a pastor, if I’m in disagreement with the elders, it’s appropriate for me to say, “Ok, this is where I’m at, this is my concern. I want us to continue to pray about this, and continue to walk through this, and we will entertain this later.” 

But it is never open to me to be able to go outside of that eldership and share my dissension or disagreement to the church or publicly. 

That’s a basic, fundamental principle that governs eldership.

So, I want you to understand that. That’s kinda some of the things play into this as we move forward. And so the decision was hard, but clear. And, uh, however, this is what I hope that you will leave here with, is that we do not in any way, shape or form want to dishonor or diminish the remarkable commitment and work that John has done here. It is extremely . . .  we planted three churches. And it is extremely hard to plant a church, to establish a church, and then to have to leave that church is an extraordinarily difficult thing to do.

So we want to honor all that he has done, and give him all the love. And we want to encourage you to pray for he and his family, and moving forward. I just want to read a passage of scripture here, that I hope can just be modeled in our relationships with everyone moving forward. So, Romans chapter 12, verses 9 and following, says this. It says, “Let love be genuine. Abhor what is evil. Hold fast to what is good. Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honor. Do not be slothful in zeal. Be fervent in spirit. Serve the Lord. Rejoice in hope. Be patient in tribulation and be constant in prayer.”

So tomorrow, we’re going to pray for John and his family and the church as we move forward. And, so, we want to make sure that personally and privately we’re continuing to pursue relationships in a way that brings glory to the Lord, and brings about peace for hurting hearts. And please understand our empathy for how hard this is. So with that said, we want you to understand that, um, directionally as a church, and as an eldership of the church, we’re going to turn the page. There will be no further public statements about this or concerning this. 

We’re not going to respond to the onslaught of media and social media, and all of that. Probably we will consider those things. But we’re going to try, our emphasis is going to be to re-focussing Harvest Naples on the mission that we have of, that Travis has already said this morning, of glorifying God through the fulfillment of the great commission. And keeping our eyes on Christ, and making disciples, and getting back on mission. 

And with that, we are currently already involved in the process of searching and finding a permanent pastor that can come in and be the pastor of this church, moving forward. And so we’ll keep you as posted as we can on that process moving forward, once we’ve kinda gotten a little further in that process. So I just wanted to address those things. The elders, both Fred and Scott are available to answer any other questions and talk with you as much as you need to talk through these things. And we will continue to pursue some of these things, not off of the table, as far as publicly. 

So, anyway, I would just like to have a moment of prayer for you, just to kinda transition with prayer as we move into a new season of ministry. So let’s go to the Lord in prayer.

Audio of Russell Taylor’s Comments:


Invitation to Q&A Meeting:

From: Harvest Bible Chapel Q & A
Sent: Sunday, February 17, 2019 9:22 PM
To: HarvestNaplesForumQues[email protected]gmail.com
Subject: Harvest Bible Chapel- Neutral/Moderated Forum Invitation

You are invited to a Neutral, Moderated Forum for members and attendees (current & former) of Harvest Bible Chapel, Naples.  Since the events that began on January 16, there has been a lot of confusion and conflicting information as to what happened and why.  There have been requests  for a forum consisting of John Secrest (former pastor), Scott Stonebreaker and Fred Ananias (Elders), where these men can help share the events that led up to Pastor Secrest being fired and the events thereafter.  

A group of members, current & former, have gathered together to organize this event  John, Scott, and Fred have all been invited to attend.  We desire this to be a neutral, moderated event.  Members, current & former, and attendees of Harvest Bible Chapel are invited to attend and listen.  

You may send up to five questions to this email address until Saturday, 2/23 at noon
.  [email protected]  The moderator (a neutral person who has never been part of HBCN) will then choose a variety of questions and ask them at the event on behalf of the attendees.  

The event is Sunday, February 24, 2019

Faith Bible Church   6464 Immokalee Rd, Naples, FL 34119  


Our hope is that this event can end the silence and bring to light what has been discussed in private.  We are praying for questions to be answered, accountability to decisions that have been made, reconciliation as we are all part of the larger body of Christ, closure for those who have been called to move on, and peace between believers here in Naples.    

May we come together as Paul extorted the church in Thessalonica:  “Now we ask you, brothers and sisters, to acknowledge those who work hard among you, who care for you in the Lord and who admonish you. Hold them in the highest regard in love because of their work. Live in peace with each other.  And we urge you, brothers and sisters, warn those who are idle and disruptive, encourage the disheartened, help the weak, be patient with everyone.  Make sure that nobody pays back wrong for wrong, but always strive to do what is good for each other and for everyone else.  Rejoice always,  pray continually,  give thanks in all circumstances;for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.”  1 Thessalonians 5:12-18  

****************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************This Neutral, Moderated Forum is being put together by a small group of Harvest Bible Chapel members

**You received this email because you have previously expressed a desire to know if such a meeting would take place.  Please know that your email address will not be used outside of this one time invitation. You will not receive additional emails unless there is an update to this event.
***Faith Bible Church has simply agreed to allow us to use their facility as a neutral space for this event.  


Russell Taylor’s Email Condemning Q&A Invitation:

Greetings Harvest Family,

As your Interim Pastor I wanted to take a moment to communicate that my wife, Christina, and I are pleased to have the opportunity to serve you during this challenging season of transition. This past Sunday we truly sensed the presence of God as we worshipped together.  We were blessed to meet some of you after the service and have enjoyed getting to know your leadership team over the last couple of weeks. We look forward to working with them and serving you as we move forward together.

I know that there are a lot of questions and concerns that some of you may have. Unfortunately, the pervasive influence of the media and the publicizing our local church’s issues have made it very difficult for your leaders to adequately address your concerns without violating their responsibilities to honor everyone involved. I can tell you for certain that they have acted out of love and patience with the goal of seeking God’s face and pursuing a smooth path to health for our church and every individual.

My wife and I have have recently met with some of you and will be diligently working to continue to give as much clarity as possible on your concerns and church direction for the future.

You may have recently received an email inviting you to a forum this coming weekend. There have been some unauthorized communication using our email list and we regret that this has brought further confusion and frustration to some of you.  We have not called this meeting and our staff and leadership will not be participating.  For future reference, any official emails will only come from a @harvestnaples.org domain. 

I want you to be assured that the Elders have participated in meetings with John Secrest and we all plan to continue to attend appropriate meetings with the goal of peacemaking.

Together, let’s humble ourselves as we pray and seek God to be glorified in our church. We are trusting in His perfect plan and covet your prayers for our staff and leadership during this time.

Should you have any questions, please feel free to reach out to me anytime at [email protected].  

I am happy to serve and be here with you.

You Are Loved,
Russell Taylor, Interim Lead Pastor
Harvest Bible Chapel Naples



Keep in touch with Julie and get updates in your inbox!

Don’t worry we won’t spam you.

More to explore

47 thoughts on “HBC Naples Interim Pastor States Cardinal Rule of Elders: “Never Share Dissension or Disagreement to the Church or Publicly””

  1. Run, Run. Now, dont get caught up in another guys power trip. Stand up for God’s sake. Don’t be sheep , (the dumb kind) . This guy basically walks into th church Seacrest started and steals it. And then blames Seacrest for standing up to the abusive governance of the Mother ship. And you Elders, shame. Run people, no amount of good sermons will make up for the over the top authority.

  2. It sounds as though the Naples cult environment will continue. It saddens me that the so-called leaders within Harvest Naples twist their words in order to make the members feel as though they are doing things in a Christian and truly loving way. Their actions dont align with their words though. It’s very sad to see the abuses continue.

  3. Wow. How frustrating and discouraging to listen to church leaders use ‘spiritual’ language to vindicate sinful policies. You would think Naples would recognize their copying HBC’s sinful pattern and wish to flee that system of church leadership. How sad. Sin flourishes in darkness and secrecy.

  4. Julie Roys, How can WE as the BODY of CHRIST help? What are we called to do as BELIEVERS of JESUS CHRIST when this happens? Asking for direction for those of us who aren’t going to be silent any longer ?

    1. It depends on the situation. But in general, we need to speak the truth in love. If there’s sin or sinful patterns in an elder board, people need to go to the elder board and confront the sin. If there’s no repentance, then people need to tell the church. If the church is part of a denomination, then go to the bishop, etc… But don’t submit to abusive leadership. Call it out. And if the leadership is intractable, then leave. We need to do everything within our power to stop this!

      1. We are. Julie this just might be a good spot to make public what I have done if you deem fit. But then again little coward Sherwood might be watching. James you can run but you can’t hide. Coward.

      2. Julie, Thanks for bringing these issues to light. First, where did he find the “Cardinal Rule of Elders”? Which Book, chapter and verse is it found in Scripture? Or Robert Rules of Order? Or The Mac Bible of Despot Leadership. Second, is Russell Taylor the right man to interim? In 2014 he incorporated two churches (inactive status) and in 2018 three businesses; one title the Vertical Church Crestview (VCC) Inc. (https://www.corporationwiki.com/Florida/Lake-City/russell-taylor-P709705.aspx) Thus if he is the church plant Pastor of VCC, how can he interim at HBC-Naples and have each congregation grow? Third, you are correct that Pastor John Secrest who planted HBC-Naples, dismissed for unjust cause be reinstated. I would add that the church pay for loss wages from the day that he was dismissed.

  5. It’s going to implode there at Naples as it should as it should here in Chicago too. To much systemic sickness. This grieves me so much to read what Russel said. No words

  6. Russell has a track record of overbearing control and has run into the ground at least two other church plants. Please warn the people of Naples and look into his churches in Lake City and Gainesville (no longer in existence).

  7. Having been members of an elder-led governed church for the last 40 or so years, we are puzzled by the continual references to pastor vs elder. In our understanding the pastor is simply one of the elders … he is not even the head/chair of the elder board. The entire elder board strives to work in a setting of mutual submission and respect … is that not in keeping with the scriptural model?

  8. Think about it. Naples was given its autonomy, but Secrest was not returned to the pulpit. Russell is an INTERIM lead pastor. Wake up! He’s a placeholder. Let’s follow JMac’s lead and place BETS on how long it will be before JMac is in the pulpit at HBC Naples. JMac walks away with WITW ministry intact, lets the heat die down and takes the pulpit at Naples, which was the plan ALL ALONG.

    1. Something tells me you are right. This may have been the only reason Naples was returned to autonomy – so that James MacDonald could take it over, take WITW/Vertical with him, and establish another fifedom.

      Any pastor that says, as Russell Taylor said, that “there is never a time when a pastor may break from elder authority–even if those elders are sinning and supporting sin, or …if the elders are capitulating to a sinning and controlling pastor…” is not a pastor that people should follow.

      The people of Naples need to rise up just as they did in Chicagoland and demand change immediately, or they should leave.

  9. Fred/ former elder

    Fire this Taylor Russell guy! He’s no pastor, he’s an imposter, and a clone of James, much like Rick Donald, Jeff Donaldson, Brit Gilman, Drew, Mo, Greg and others like them! They’re all complicit to the gills! Throw in the worship leaders as well, they with false tears and false testimonies!!

    1. It’s really hard to see Jeff’s name in that list. He was so approachable, kind hearted and truly helpful spiritually to my husband and I while we were at Harvest. I’ve worked for a manipulative person before. It can really mess you up. I wonder if he should be given a chance to be out from under.

  10. bless your heart Julie… Harvest is not the only institutional church that uses this “no talk” rule with leadership… executive sessions are essentially a gag order on the leaders in the reformed traditions as well… and quite likely other denoms, but my experience is in the reformed traditions….

  11. Apparently, all these so called “pastors” are either ignorant of how social media has made them hiding things, so “yesterday”. People with discernment have to call them out and make them accountable, The “code of silence” is no longer believable and the continuation policy
    of coverup is destroying the message to those “unchurched.”

    1. Exactly Thomas! Do you think when telephonic were invented they are screamed about that?? Don’t call your neighbor on the phone!! Haha seriously these guys are younger than me and they don’t get it’s a whole new game with the internet?? Transparency is a must

  12. I don’t necessarily disagree with leadership staying quiet when there’s disagreement, but that should simply be a guiding principle, not something to be applied in situations where blatant sin is taking place within the leadership. I’d also like to point out that churches need to be REALLY CAREFUL signing over their autonomy to a large network of churches. STOP signing covenants that allow elders to harass its church members into submission, even when it’s simply a disagreement.

    These churches talk about grace so much, it’s morphed into punishment.

  13. This is SO WRONG. How much time, energy and sacrifice did Secreast and his family give to build that church? Unbelievable. The congregation should demand he return. Heartbreaking.

    1. You all are so right: What’s being done at Naples is SO WRONG. So much deep sin from the 2 so-called “elders” and the new Interim. Unbelievable. Was so hoping–and praying–they’d do the right thing and reinstate Pastor Secrest!

  14. It will be interesting to see how the church in Naples itself responds to this. Hopefully, it will see this as what it is and addresses it as such. Otherwise, what was all the pain for in the first place?

  15. I too work for a very large corporation and so I am intimately knowledgeable about the graft, corruption, intimidation, and nepotism that is Harvest Inc.

    We have a saying on our job, “Nothing changes except the faces.”

    And that is why we need the watchmen and blogs such as TED and Julie’s at this time more than ever.

    They are trying to rehabilitate the corporation. So I ask that good people will not let that happen for all of the unsuspecting masses caught up in the corporation’s cognitive dissonance that has been inflicted upon them.

  16. My mom attended CL harvest seasonally for several years. She heard James Macdonald talk about how they plant churches instead of supporting missionaries. Because she never once heard a contrary word or warning about James Macdoanld character and wasn’t always there year round to maybe get a full dose James teaching enough for her discerner to get peaked, she believed this church planting over missionaries idea. So in 2015 she called the Secrests who she has known since John was a teenager, just as he was going to take another job at a church in Nebraska. She excitedly told him about HBF and he looked into it. At that point it was his decision to move forward. But I want to point out the Secrests were connected to HArvest bible fellowship because of the good faith my mom had in HArvest bible chapel Crystal lake. My moms good faith in HBF/HBC was in a round about way used by HBC to geeedily pounce on her friends and tear up the hard work the secrests did. I think my mom deserves a small apology and the Secrests deserve a huge apology!

  17. Sad and Moving On

    During the January Elgin Harvest Q&A, Jeff Donaldson told 200 people that John Seacrest was already in trouble and on his way out before the firing.

    1. Are you kidding me??? Well Jeff Donaldson can’t wait for the day if the whole story comes out. That’s probably why they are so afraid in Naples to give John Secrest a chance to tell his side. I hope he goes on the Mancow show!

  18. don’t worry everyone. the location of this harvest naples florida is way southeast on the back end of the greater naples area. The people that live out in this area are your walmart workers and applebee servers. there will never be enough tithe money to warrant Jmac and crew to ever purchase this church and it’s property nor stay put. They will be on the move elsewhere before you know it.

    1. I agree Sasha and even the building itself is a logistical nightmare. It can only hold a few hundred. With that small and now no longer attatched to the mothership it will never be able to grow a big enough congregation to bring in $ to expand. It’s juat the principal of what was done there and still no sorrow, no apology and they are just trying to sweep it all under a rug!

    2. Is Naples growing that direction or would it take too many years?
      Recently stayed at a hotel there and I had the same impression of the area.
      Definitely not upscale.

  19. “unauthorized communication” ? Sounds like preposterous shenanigan by some sect ot communist organization. Naples, give yourself a break. You will find more God on the beach than in this place where your are manipulated and controlled.

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.

Leave a Reply

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people register before they begin commenting. This means no anonymous comments will be allowed. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
MOST popular articles


Hi. We see this is the third article this month you’ve found worth reading. Great! Would you consider making a tax-deductible donation to help our journalists continue to report the truth and restore the church?

Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. This month we’re offering a beautiful “The Roys Report” branded mug to anyone who gives a gift of $25/mo or more.