Summit Church—a large, multi-site church in south Florida—has announced that one of its main pastor/elders has been removed after admitting he stole money from the church.
In a statement released to The Roys Report, Summit stated that Jim Hines, formerly listed on the Summit website as a directing elder, was caught stealing money from an offering on Christmas Eve. Hines also admitted to stealing cash from the church in 2018, the statement said. Summit said Hines’ employment has been terminated.
At the end of Summit’s livestreamed service on Sunday, Jamin Stinziano, another directing elder at Summit, announced to the congregation that there would be an important “family meeting” following the service “because there’s some things we need to share with you.” That family meeting was not livestreamed, but reportedly addressed the issue with Hines.
Summit Church, which began in 2003 on the campus of Florida Gulf Coast University, has three campuses. Its University Campus and Gateway Campus are in Fort Myers. A third campus is in Naples. According to Summit’s website, the church practices an “Interdependent Leadership” model, which includes seven (now six) directing elders with equal authority who “lead under the authority and headship of Jesus Christ.”
In addition to his position with Summit Church, Hines also is listed as being on the leadership team at Saturation Church Planting, a fellowship of churches committed to “gospel saturation in North America.”
Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “Jesus v. Evangelicals: A Biblical Critique of a Wayward Movement” by Constantine Campbell. To donate, click here.
According to Summit’s statement, Hines was first accused of taking cash during an offering count in 2018. “That charge was taken seriously and Jim was put on leave,” the church said. “At that time, he denied the accusation and ultimately it could not be confirmed.”
However, the statement adds that Hines “was seen violating one of our protective policies” on Christmas Eve. This led to Hines “being caught stealing $1,000 from an offering. He also has admitted to stealing when he was initially accused in 2018.”
The church said it is conducting a full investigation with the help of third parties to determine if other theft may have occurred. When asked if the church has reported the theft to local authorities, Communications Pastor Joe O’Neal responded, “I can’t comment on anything right now as we’re still gathering information.”
7 thoughts on “Large Florida Church Removes Pastor for Stealing From Offerings”
Many churches today have become entertainment venues. Focus is not on Jesus, sin and hell never discussed (it may upset the sheep). Sickening what the church has become.
I’ve been to the University Campus several times. Good place. Good people.
How would they be able to assess cash gifts that were stolen prior to being counted? They need law enforcement to look into his finances.
The pastor can’t comment yet regarding if they have contacted the authorities?? Something doesn’t sound right here. Makes me wonder if they are afraid of what else the authorities may uncover if they look into this.
Joe O’Neal said they couldn’t comment on anything at the present time. Standard operating procedure.
I like the idea of the “family meeting”, with its possibility of dealing with matters within the Church. I understand and endorse the mandatory requirement to notify secular authorities and see matters made transparent in the public domain, for particular matters of offense (such as sexual offending and any offense to do with a minor). However, faith and faith communities stand in a complex relation to the secular and the wider-collective, such that it’s good to see actions intending to preserve aspects of what is singular to faith.
That being said, I don’t know what the law requires in the USA. Is it mandatory to report theft and lies associated with theft, to secular authorities?
It concerns me that the “emergency family meeting” wasn’t livestreamed. What is Summit Church hiding from the brethren and the world?
The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
Comments are limited to 300 words.