As I mentioned in an earlier blog post, Harvest Bible Chapel (HBC) has told two different narratives to two different audiences concerning the recent firing of Pastor John Secrest from HBC Naples—the church Secrest planted in 2016.
In Chicago, on January 19-20, a very mournful group of elders admitted “shortcomings” concerning Secrest’s “termination” and pledged to try and “move forward in a healthy way.” However, in Naples, elder Fred Ananias reportedly didn’t even tell the congregation that Secrest had been fired. He simply said it had been a hard week and encouraged people to come to him or elder Scott Stonebreaker with their questions.
That silence was a glaring omission. But now there’s evidence that Ananias lied.
As I reported in WORLD Magazine, Ananias was the one who visited Secrest at his home on January 18 and fired him in person. This happened just hours after Secrest had sent an email to his congregation, expressing his objection to Harvest’s decision to allow James MacDonald, Harvest’s embattled celebrity pastor, to preach in Naples during his “indefinite sabbatical.” Secrest also told his congregation that he had asked Harvest to return HBC Naples to independent governance. (HBC Naples had signed a ministry agreement in September making it a wholly-owned subsidiary of Harvest.)
“When Harvest placed MacDonald on sabbatical three weeks ago . . . the church said it was entering a ‘peacemaking process.’ Yet there’s been nothing conciliatory about Harvest’s handling of Secrest and HBC Naples.”
Give a gift of $25 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “I Can’t Hear God Anymore: Life in A Dallas Cult” by Wendy Duncan. To donate, click here.
I emailed Ananias, specifically asking him about Housewert’s account, but he did not respond.
However, Debra Szemplinski, who also attended services in Naples on January 20, said a security volunteer likewise told her that Secrest had not been fired, but had willfully resigned. In addition, the letter Ananias and the other Naples leaders sent to the Naples congregation never stated that Secrest had been fired either. Instead, it claimed that Secrest “no longer desires to work for Harvest Bible Chapel,” and it has “become clear that he should not continue in his role.”
Another disturbing report involves Secrest’s private Facebook account.
Secrest told me that immediately after he sent the fateful email to his congregation on January 18, he was locked out of his Harvest email account. Yet two days later, he received notification from Facebook that someone had used his Harvest email to hack into his private Facebook page. For 20 minutes, Seacrest said he was shut out of his own Facebook account, and someone had access to all his private messages and information.
Secrest said he reported the Facebook hacking to authorities, who are investigating.
When Harvest placed MacDonald on sabbatical three weeks ago due to ongoing allegations of bullying, deception, and financial misconduct, the church said it was entering a “peacemaking process.” Yet there’s been nothing conciliatory about Harvest’s handling of Secrest and HBC Naples.
I talked to Secrest this past weekend, and he confirmed that there has been no attempt by Harvest to reconcile with him. Instead, Harvest officially removed Secrest as an officer of HBC Naples on January 23 and changed the church address from Secrest’s home to the building the church is renting for services.
According to the official state of Florida website, the only two officers of HBC Naples now are Scott Stonebreaker and Fred Ananias.
Who’s Running HBC Naples?
Over the past couple weeks, I have repeatedly tried to get updates from Harvest on what’s happening with Secrest and HBC Naples, but Harvest says it won’t comment while its “peacemaking process is underway.” However, several sources have told me that Harvest has returned HBC Naples to local governance, as Secrest requested several weeks ago.
One of them is Aaron Tull—a Naples resident who began attending HBC Naples in March of 2018 but recently left the church over Secrest’s firing. Tull said Travis Doucette, HBC Naples worship and leadership development pastor, told him that Harvest in Chicago had returned the church to its previous independence. However, Tull said Doucette told him that the church has no intention of bringing Secrest back, but instead is looking for a new pastor.
I called Doucette to try and confirm Tull’s report, but he hung up on me as soon as I identified myself. I also have emailed both HBC Naples elders—Scott Stonebreaker and Fred Ananias— but neither has responded. Both are still listed on Harvest’s website as members of Harvest’s 34-member elder board.
I also have contacted Doug and Joyce Bartholomew, the owners of the building that HBC Naples reportedly is leasing for $10/year. Neither was willing to speak with me.
“Yet even if HBC Naples has become independent from Harvest in Chicago, there’s no indication that its remaining leadership is independent from MacDonald.”
Yet even if HBC Naples has become independent from Harvest in Chicago, there’s no indication that its remaining leadership is independent from MacDonald.
Naples Elder Scott Stonebreaker went on a week-long golf trip in England with MacDonald last July. Also, Doug Bartholomew sent an accusatory email to John Secrest on January 22. Among his accusations was an assertion that Secrest refused to “submit to biblical elder leadership, while joining those who oppose James McDonald (sic).”
Bartholomew also accused Secrest of claiming “not to have known about the controversy around MacDonald when actually we talked about it in our earliest discussions.”
Secrest responded that he had been aware of the problems at Harvest, which are documented at The Elephant’s Debt, for several years. However, at the time of the merger in September, he said he was not aware of my investigation of Harvest, nor of the lawsuit against me and four others, “which (Harvest) had certainly been contemplating before (HBC Naples) signed the ministry agreement.”
Secrest said he doesn’t want to share anymore details about the events leading up to the merger publicly until he’s had a chance to talk face-to-face with his former congregation. He said he sent a letter to Stonebreaker and Ananias this past weekend requesting a congregational meeting, but has not yet heard back from them.
Many at HBC Naples Remain in the Dark
Much of the congregation in Naples seems unaware of the issues with MacDonald and Harvest. Xochytl Rodriguez-Cantu, who began attending HBC Naples in November, told me that she knew nothing about the current controversy. She added that she knew elders had put MacDonald on an indefinite “sabbatical,” but didn’t know why.
Carolyn Housewert, Mike Housewert’s wife, said she was ignorant of issues with MacDonald when the couple first started attending HBC Naples several weeks ago. Housewert said she initially liked the church so much that she brought about 10 friends to HBC Naples. Then, when she shared her enthusiasm about the church with friends from out of state, they forwarded articles critical of MacDonald to her, which made her feel “sick.” Now, she said she doesn’t think she and her husband can stay at the Naples church.
Tull said he became aware of the lawsuit MacDonald and Harvest had filed when he googled MacDonald’s name last October. He said the lawsuit concerned him, but it didn’t seem to concern anybody else at church. Most, he said, didn’t even know about it.
Randy Huizinga and his girlfriend, Elizabeth D’Acquisto, said they didn’t know anything about the lawsuit or other issues until very recently. This, despite the fact that they were among the original core group that started the church.
However, in January, Huizinga said a friend sent him the WORLD article I had written, as well as news of the church’s lawsuit. “We kind of felt like a bomb blew up,” D’Acquisto said. Yet the couple said they were planning to stay at the church until Harvest fired Secrest. For them, that was the last straw.
Secrest’s firing was the final straw for Tull, too. Yet he added that he’s been “shocked” at how many people have been willing to accept it.
Evidently, a sizable number of the congregation has not been willing to accept what’s happened to Secrest, though. The church, which had been running two services on Sunday morning, has returned to just one.
I will continue to report updates as they become available.
48 thoughts on “The Latest on Harvest Naples: A Lie, a Hack, and Who’s Running the Church?”
Good evening, Mr. Bartholomew. I appreciate you chiming in. Would you be able to answer a few questions regarding your comments?
1) What “lie” about Secrest’s termination are you referring to? I’m not clear.
2) It’s my understanding that HBC terminated Mr. Secrest within hours of him sending his email. Is it common practice in the business world to fire people upon receiving an email like that? Would you consider his email “insubordinate”? This is also a church we’re talking about, not a Fortune 500 company. So even if Goldman Sachs would terminate upon receipt of such an email, are you saying that immediate termination was warranted, given that this is a church? Should there not have been a dialogue or meeting with Mr. Secrest? Should these matters be handled differently among believers than I secular settings?
3) Are you in possession or do you have knowledge of evidence that challenges Mr. Secrest’s observations/suspicions about his email and FB accounts?
4) You said Mr. Ananias and Mr. Stonebreaker were at HBC Naples long before James was involved. Mr. Ananias started attending a week after HBC Naples started in November 2016. Mr. Stonebreaker came after that. Both men were instated as Elders in February 2018, I believe. Were you aware that both men had friendships/relationships with James previously? Did you know that James MacDonald preached several times at HBC Peoria (Fred’s home church) and that Mr. Stonebreaker had attended HBC Elgin?
5) Can you comment on Mr. Stonebreaker’s golf trip to Europe with James MacDonald? To your knowledge, did that trip come before or after HBC Naples had agreed to become a wholly-own subsidiary of HBC Chicago?
6) I recall that your wife had said that you approached Mr. Stonebreaker about the building lease before James/HBC Chicago were involved. I believe you. Can you say which month that was in, approximately?
7) When you say that an overwhelming majority of your congregation support Elders Ananias and Stonebreaker, what do you mean by “support”? Support the decision to terminate John Secrest, or something else?
8) Can you shed some light on what HBC Naples had to “gain” from becoming part of HBC Chicago? You noted that the building lease had already been offered prior to HBC Chicago proposing the HBC Naples become an 8th campus. Were you involved in the decision for HBC Naples to cease being independent? What were the benefits and drawbacks, from your perspective?
9) Is HBC Naples independent again, or is there a plan for it to become independent?
10) Who is the Lead Pastor (or Interim Lead Pastor) of HBC Naples right now?
Thanks for your time.
just for Julie:
For 20 minutes, Seacrest (sic)
turnabout is fair play!
You would think you would know how to spell Johns last name correctly. Your incompetence is shown all around! Have fun with that stupid church building you bought haha
Hi Doug. First, you may have missed my question above. When did your & your wife approach Mr. Stonebreaker about using the property owned by your foundation? In what month? May 2018?
No one is “singling out” Harvest or James. There are real sins that have been committed–and are still being committed–against both individuals and the church body. Among other things, HBC & James have mishandled money and refused to open the books or disclose salaries. Did you know that James said that he would rather lose 1000 sheep than disclose his salary? He then cited the “loss” of 2500 sheep (i.e., their tithes) in the defamation lawsuit he filed to scare Julie Roys into silence. Didn’t work.
This morning, Mancow played snippets of recordings of James. Did you hear about that yet? Among other things, there’s audio of James talking about planting child porn on the Christianity Today editor’s computer. (The show should be available later today. I’m hoping Julie will post about it.) I think you should take a listen.
James MacDonald is disqualified from ministry on multiple counts. Please don’t publicly support this man until you have the full story. I know his church spent money to improve your property, but that shouldn’t cloud your ability to see the truth.
Apologies to all for multiple comments posted! The one on Feb 10 was only just posted, and I posted twice today after my first comment apparently not going through. Must be my browser!
FINAL POST –
Regarding the ‘hack’ allegation, I have good reasons to question the veracity of that claim. However, I do not have enough detail to say with certainty what happened, and I presume what information I have was given in confidence. As for the accusation of Ananias lying, I have since learned he categorically denies telling anyone Secrest resigned. There is no way to prove anything, but my hunch is that no one (Ananias, Julie, or her source) is lying, but there was miscommunication. Anyone who has played telephone knows how readily words can be innocently miscommunicated. At any rate, this article is the first I ever heard of anyone being told John resigned.
My involvement has always been due to concern that false accusations were being layered on top of legitimate concerns. It was especially troubling to see people state that the situation in Naples was the last straw – the turning point in their assessment of James / Harvest – which is unfair in my opinion.
Having said that, my expertise begins and ends in Naples. The whole truth is yet to come out, and my belief is that many accusations will be found false or significantly exaggerated. Nevertheless, this has always been a matter for the elders to arbitrate and they have spoken. As the loser says after a soccer match, “congratulations, good game, your team wins.”
It’s Doug Bartholomew’s belief that many of the allegations will come out to be False. Well Douglas we have seen the caliber of your heart in your ever so awesome elephantitus blog. So it’s no surprise that you find a pastor taking about planting child porn on a ceo’s computer as no big deal, just false and significantly exaggerated kinda stuff. I mean that’s totally normal for someone to say. I mean afterall it’s just pictures of the most vile evil horrific crime that exists. And you know something a totally normal pastor reverts to threatening someones entire livliehood with that topic as just a joke! You know haha funny type of joke.
Pride, arrogance and flat-out greed has destroyed a once awesome institution. It seems that everything Harvest touches becomes corrupted and defiled. Satan wins again……for now.
Yes. Bartholomew’s tone holds the same condescension that comes from MacDonald, Dallas Jenkins, & Jeff Donaldson. They are entitled and, because of that, act like jerks.
This is what comes from any institution that values centralized control; inevitably, it becomes abusive and those surrounding the pit boss do whatever they can to protect him because their hands are just as dirty.
This is a good example of what I mean: Diane Langberg: Beware of leaders in a narcissistic church culture who think they can orchestrate their own repentance and restoration. This is the height of arrogance.
The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
Comments are limited to 300 words.