Willow Creek Community Church has just announced it has hired former Harvest Bible Chapel Chicago Cathedral Pastor Ed Ollie as the next pastor of Willow Creek North Shore. Ollie also will serve on Willow’s main teaching team.
Ollie replaces popular Willow Creek North Shore Pastor Amy Mikal, who resigned at the end of September.
On October 8, Ollie resigned his position at Harvest after pastoring Harvest through a difficult time, following the termination of disgraced senior pastor, James MacDonald.
Ollie said he realized during a “goal review” last August that his time at Harvest “was coming to an end.”
“I’m in a space where, while I’m excited, I’m also mourning because this is an amazing church,” Ollie said at the time.
Give a gift of $25 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “I Can’t Hear God Anymore: Life in A Dallas Cult” by Wendy Duncan. To donate, click here.
According to an email from Willow Creek Executive Pastor Tim Stevens to all church staff, Willow first had conversations with Ollie in July and August. At that time, however, “(W)e didn’t have any specific positions that would be a good fit for him.”
Stevens said that in the meantime, “unrelated to our conversations with him,” Ollie decided to step down from his position at Harvest. And over the last few weeks, Willow Creek staff and WCNS lay leaders have met with Ollie.
“(A)s each meeting took place, we become more convinced of Ed’s fit to pastor the North Shore congregation in this next season,” Stevens wrote.
Upheaval at North Shore Campus
Willow’s announcement comes during a period of major upheaval at Willow Creek North Shore.
Not only has Mikal recently resigned. Last month, Willow announced sweeping changes, which included the elimination of 92 jobs churchwide, including 13 at the North Shore campus.
Since then, an additional 14 WCNS staff have taken a buyout plan, leaving only five of the original 32 staff remaining at the campus.
The changes have incensed many members of the WCNS congregation and led to two very tense meetings between the congregation and Willow’s central leadership earlier this month. (The Roys Report will be publishing an article soon about the upheaval at WCNS.)
According to an announcement posted to YouTube, Mikal resigned from Willow Creek after speaking with the “new Willow leadership” and hearing about their “new vision and strategy” for the future.
“I spent so many sleepless nights listening for God’s voice,” Mikal said. “And at the end, it broke my heart because it became clear God was turning the page on the chapter where I serve as the lead pastor at Willow Creek North Shore.”
In an FAQ Willow published on October 7, the church stated that Mikal had been asked to stay on at Willow in a different role. But Mikal, whose passion for “teaching and preaching” has grown, reportedly didn’t feel “the new job description fits her passions and strengths.”
The FAQ also responded to questions about whether Willow had moved Mikal out of a teaching role because Willow “no longer value(s) women in leadership.”
(Pastor Dave Dummit, who became Willow’s senior pastor in April, comes from a multi-site church in Michigan where all the campus pastors are male. Willow, on the other hand, has historically had women serving as both pastors and elders.)
The FAQ states, “Dave comes from a church where he moved them from a more conservative stance to a church that opened doors for women to preach on the weekends.” The document also notes that Dummit hired Megan Marshman to serve on Willow’s teaching team.
Additionally, in Stevens’ email to church staff today, he mentions that one of the reasons Ollie was “attracted to Willow is our high value for women leading at every level in the church.”
Stevens said Ollie will begin “easing into his role” in November and will be “fully engaged” by early December.
“Please be praying for Ed and his family as they join the North Shore family,” Stevens said. “Please also be praying for the North Shore staff and congregation as they continue to walk through significant change.”Update concerning North Shore_Redacted
7 thoughts on “Willow Creek Hires Former Harvest Pastor Ed Ollie to Replace Popular Pastor at North Shore Campus”
As predicted, Willow now has 10 men and only 1 woman on their senior leadership team, having lost one woman and hired 4 men since longtime complementarian new senior pastor Dave Dummitt took over earlier this year. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1aAHE6vSnZZSSuG7Rrhk3ju5eX2ZEjxVGepguLDIOTK4/edit?usp=sharing
Did the NS attenders get a vote? Are the leaders listening to the sheep? Are those tithing being heard? or chased away. Does anyone see the importance?
Put your faith in God. He will nurture you
I’m glad to see Willow Creek following the Scriptures more carefully concerning leadership and the role of men in primary preaching positions.
Ed “I’m trusting in the Lord with no idea where I will land” Ollie must have been fast tracked by WC given his recent blind future resignation from HBC.
Wash, rinse, repeat
With all due respect to Willow Creek, and to Amy Mikal, the role of Pastor is limited to MEN, and women should not serve in positions of final authority over Men (1 Timothy 2:11-14; 1 Timothy 3:1-7; Titus 1:6-9; 1 Cor 11:2-11). So, I hope the Church gets it right and choose godly Men to lead the Congregation.
The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
Comments are limited to 300 words.