Tonight, an historic cathedral in northwestern England will host a “punk rock night” where participants will drink cocktails and dance to raucous music. The event is one of several rock and disco events being held in cathedrals affiliated with the Church of England, which have prompted protests by thousands who see the events as “profane.”

The organizer, Silent Discos in Incredible Places, has hosted events with live DJs, LED lights, and fully stocked mobile bars in museums and other landmarks. Leaders of several historic cathedrals view the disco events as a means to attract younger congregants and help cover rising maintenance costs.

But for many of the faithful, holding discos in cathedrals goes too far. They especially objected to a disco held at the nation’s oldest church, Canterbury Cathedral, founded in 597 and recognized as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. Canterbury Cathedral held a ‘silent disco’ on Feb. 8 and 9.

Despite an petición en línea launched prior to that event, the sold-out disco at Canterbury Cathedral proceeded as planned. Revelers danced on the graves of saints to hits by Eminem, Spice Girls, and Britney Spears. Ten more events are planned at historic UK churches, including tonight’s punk rock bash at Manchester Cathedral.

Currently, more than 2,700 people have signed a petition to the Church of England, with some signees concurrently holding prayer vigils outside the church disco events.

“Dear Anglican Deans, please stop the discos and make the Cathedrals houses of prayer once more,” the petition states in part. “We the undersigned oppose all desecration of our historic holy places, and especially their use as nightclubs.” 

Covering the Canterbury disco event, Catholic journalist Edward Pentin shared video footage and wrote: “Canterbury Cathedral, where St Thomas Becket was martyred just next to the nave, is hosting a ‘90s Silent Disco’ (in the) Anglican cathedral, originally built by Catholics and consecrated in 1070. Alcohol was also on sale from makeshift bars at the side of the nave.”

Canterbury Cathedral, where St Thomas Becket was martyred just next to the nave, is hosting a “90s Silent Disco” over two nights Feb. 8-9. 3,000 people expected to take part. Faithful are protesting against the event with prayer vigils outside @CburyCathedral pic.twitter.com/wFwsUMALsD

— Edward Pentin (@EdwardPentin) February 9, 2024

London-based evangelical author Tim Dieppe, affiliated with public policy group Christian Concern, llamado the disco event a “desperate attempt to attract people” that reflects “lost confidence in the gospel.” 

He added: “Christians laboured and gave sacrificially for years to build awe-inspiring places dedicated to the worship of God. Yet today, the Church thinks an alcohol-fuelled rave is the only way to get people into the building.” 

Similarly, Tom Alberto, a former University of Kent student who prayed outside the disco event, told local outlet KMTV that many believers object to the dance events.

“Music that is the very opposite of holy—profane—is being played,” he said. “It’s definitely going to bring people into the church tonight. But they will not be here on Sunday morning.” 

History writer David Christian, who runs the Hidden History channel on YouTube, admitted that he is “not particularly religious” and enjoys dance music. But he said in a video recap, “This just doesn’t sit right . . . (having) partygoers dancing on graves.” 

“To have a tacky and boozy 90’s disco with poorly executed singing and the waving of plastic light sticks is not just anachronistic but insulting,” said Christian. “(T)he current custodians of this transcendent national treasure either do not know or do not care about the weight of history and spiritual magnitude of this place.” 

Initially, the historic cathedral promoted the disco event and pushed back against critics.

“It is categorically not a ‘rave in the nave,’” said the Very Rev. Dr. David Monteith, dean of Canterbury, in a declaración para The Guardian. “But I appreciate that some will never agree that dancing and pop music have a place within cathedrals.”

Since then, church officials have not addressed a growing chorus of criticism. Multiple social media publicaciones with video clips of the disco event at Canterbury Cathedral were quietly removed. 

A spokesperson for Silent Discos in Incredible Places fijado to media that the group has “utmost respect” for historic cathedrals. It described silent discos as “an innocent, feelgood event focused on bringing people together to sing the songs they love in spectacular surroundings.”

Yet the group’s social media posts strike a different tone. “THANK YOU Peterborough for coming to boogie with us on the weekend at the spectacular Peterborough Cathedral,” reads one correo. 

Petition organizer Cajetan Skowronski, a medical doctor in Sussex, ha escrito at length about the prayer-centric protests outside cathedral disco events. He lamented the majority of Christians “expressing their approval by their silence,” while noting the prayer vigils have united Christians across multiple traditions. 

“We pray simply because we must glorify God outside His temple when He is profaned within.”

Periodista independiente Josh Shepherd escribe sobre fe, cultura y políticas públicas para varios medios outlets. He and his family live in the Washington, D.C. area.