Screenshot 2023-01-13 at 1.50.18 PM


Reporting the Truth.
Restoring the Church.

Pastor On Leave Months After Allegations He Helped Cover Up Relative’s Abuse

By Sarah Einselen
Jared Olivetti Reformed Presbyterian
Jared Olivetti, senior pastor at Immanuel Reformed Presbyterian Church in West Lafayette, Indiana, has been accused of helping cover-up his own relative’s abuse of multiple children. (Photo: RP Global Alliance)

An Indiana pastor has been placed on leave, about a month after accusations surfaced that he helped cover up his relative’s abuse of multiple children, the Indianapolis Star has reported.

Jared Olivetti, senior pastor at Immanuel Reformed Presbyterian Church in West Lafayette, Indiana, was placed on leave last week by the governing body of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America. News of the action was announced in a letter Thursday from the denomination and reported by the IndyStar.

In early December, allegations that Olivetti had covered up sexual crimes committed by a teenage relative were published by local media. Yet Olivetti preached at Immanuel as recently as January 2, the church’s sermon archive shows.

The Roys Report left a message seeking comment from the church but did not immediately hear back.

This past Sunday, January 9, David Hanson, senior pastor at Southside Reformed Presbyterian Church in Indianapolis, preached at Immanuel.

Your tax-deductible gift helps our journalists report the truth and hold Christian leaders and organizations accountable. Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “Baptistland: A Memoir of Abuse, Betrayal, and Transformation” by Christa Brown. To donate, click here.

“My being here today is one of the hardest things I’ve done because there’s a certain amount of failure for me to be standing here today,” Hanson, a longtime friend of Olivetti’s, said during the sermon. “This is not where I envisioned or want to be, yet this is exactly where the Lord has placed us today. I grieve with you and don’t pretend to be able to fill in in any adequate way.”

Olivetti helped plant Immanuel Reformed in 2007.

An ecclesiastical trial against Olivetti is pending. The letter from the denomination’s Synod Judicial Commission acknowledges “the gravity of the accusations” and states that Olivetti is to remain on leave until the church’s judicial process is over, the newspaper reported.

Three other elders also face ecclesiastical charges. Charges were dropped against two former elders who resigned after the presbytery investigated.

Pastor Hanson told the West Lafayette church on Sunday that he’d known Olivetti and one of the other elders facing charges since they’d met in college in the 1990s.

“Just to be very, very clear, I dearly love and admire and cherish my friendship with the Olivettis,” he said. “. . . But as dear as the last 25 years of friendship are with so many of you, how much dearer the eternity that we have to spend together, and that the Lord has plans and purposes for all of us that he is working out. So we come to the Lord this morning seeking his comfort, seeking his guidance, seeking the presence of the Holy Spirit in our midst. . . .”

Olivetti is accused of using his authority to interfere with his church’s investigation into a teenage boy’s abuse of other children at the church. Parents previously told the IndyStar the teen abused their children multiple ways, from touching over and under clothes to oral-genital contact and penetration.

Denominational authorities appointed an ecclesiastical judicial commission months after the first allegations surfaced. Church documents show the commission considered charging Olivetti with leading the church in a way that’s contrary to God’s law, but the presbytery didn’t pursue the charges.

Shawn Anderson, pastor of Sycamore Reformed Presbyterian Church in Kokomo, Indiana, was one of the presbytery’s investigators. He said the presbytery appointed him and two others to bring formal charges against Olivetti. However, Anderson said the presbytery ultimately “waited to see how the synod would handle the complaints that came before them.”

Since the synod decided to take jurisdiction, the matter was removed from the presbytery’s responsibility, Anderson said.

Olivetti’s church trial on the synod’s charges is expected to start in March, the IndyStar reported. The other charged elders are to face trial separately.

Sarah Einselen is an award-winning writer and editor based in Texas.



Keep in touch with Julie and get updates in your inbox!

Don’t worry we won’t spam you.

More to explore

4 Responses

  1. As reported, and regards the allegations made against Jared Olivetti, it would appear that his Church and denomination have acted properly, and well within the parameters of relevant procedure. Certainly if we accept the principle of innocent until proven guilty.
    The expedient circumstance regards prompter action, would attach to the allegations made against the alleged sexual offender. Presumably such action has already taken place.
    While Olivetti and the two elders now face serious synod (and then possibly criminal charges) regards obstructing the required expedient action, the expediency consideration does not attach to them. The Church and denomination have moved much quicker than is usually the case in civil and criminal trial instances, regards such obstruction.
    Bottom line here. Emotions and thinking relevant to one aspect of events, should be carefully kept separate from other aspects of events.
    If the alleged offender did as alleged; that is dreadfully serious. If Olivetti and two elders did as alleged; that is very serious. However, neither of those aspects should be leveraged to criticise the Church or denomination; at least and until any evidence justifying that criticism emerges.

    1. Snakes will be snakes. Nothing has changed in 2 millennia. The system is foul and no one really cares to do much about it. Did Jesus not say, “what you do to the least of these you have done onto me?” Such actions are not Christian but simply carnal and demonic.

    2. I find your prose difficult to follow, Mr. Bowman, but you seem to be saying that Mr. Jared Olivetti and his elders may safely be presumed to be innocent because this is a guiding principle in our legal system. However, there was a preponderance of evidence of wrongdoing: FIFTEEN children were alleged to have been abused. This is evidence of a large-scale predator and the only proper response is swift disclosure, both to the congregation and to law enforcement. Instead, there was a concerted effort by Mr. Olivetti and his elders to conceal the extent of harm done. Those who had been victimized were left to fend for themselves. This is not the action of a good shepherd: a good shepherd cares for the sheep, the hired hand abandons them.

  2. I offer my sincerest prayers and support for all of those members affected by this. I think it would be best for their church community to really take time to think about a lot of things and really take time to just heal after such an event. Church podcasts are a good alternative, should there be a chance of ceasing live church activities. Me myself always listen to Keion Henderson’s specially when live face to face worship was prohibited due to Covid.

Leave a Reply

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people register before they begin commenting. This means no anonymous comments will be allowed. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
MOST popular articles