Bob Jones University Board May Oust President For Relaxing Fundamentalist Practices

By Steve Rabey
Bob Jones University
Since 2014, Steve Pettit has served as president of Bob Jones University in Greenville, South Carolina. (Courtesy Photos)

Christian institutions face a never-ending challenge: Which cultural changes should we embrace as we prepare for the future? The challenge is starker at Bob Jones University, the bastion of American fundamentalism for nearly a century.

Disagreements over changes made at the school during the eight-year tenure of Steve Pettit, the school’s fifth president and first from outside the Jones family, broke out following an Oct. 4 board meeting in which some board members said they would let Pettit go rather than renew his current contract.

That decision has now been delayed until Nov. 17. Pettit’s current contract ends on Dec. 1.

The opposition to Pettit has nothing to do with morality or doctrine, but with “preferences of Christian practice,” according to one alumnus.

The alumnus, who talked to board members, said Pettit had been criticized for the style of worship music played at student chapel services, “immodest clothing” worn by female athletes, questionable performances and musical selections from the fine arts program, and even Pettit’s participation in a bluegrass music band.

Give a gift of $30 or more to The Roys Report this month, and you will receive a copy of “Wounded Faith,” edited by Rev. Dr. Neil Damgaard. To donate, click here.

Some board members have also blamed Pettit for firing some of the school’s most conservative professors during a time of budget cuts. But defenders say that decisions about which professors to release were made by college deans and leaders, not Pettit.

Jones III, who served as the school’s president from 1971 to 2005, wrote an open letter defending Pettit’s critics. “Your concerns for the future of the University are not unwarranted,” he wrote:

Over the last year some embarrassing, antithetical things, historically uncharacteristic things, which would have never happened in the past have occurred. From all over the country the Board received pleas from graduates, and others, to look into these matters fearing that the University had veered in its direction, and unique distinctives without which it would become irrelevant. Naturally, the Board was obligated, by reason of its existence, to step in.

Jones called the board “the protector of the institution’s character” and said it would work to seek “the root cause from which the declensions of the last year have emanated and firmness to do whatever is necessary, however painful, to stop the hemorrhage.”

Chris Anderson, a ministry leader who runs Church Works Media, is among Pettit’s supporters, writing a Nov. 4 “Open Letter from Ministry Leaders” that expressed “a collective voice of support for the leadership of Dr. Pettit.”

“Like you, we are separatists who are unwilling to tolerate or cooperate with unorthodoxy,” wrote Anderson, who reaffirmed the school’s commitment to “The Fundamentals,” a movement-defining series of books launched in 1910. He wrote:

Has BJU abandoned its commitment to six-day creationism or its opposition to evolution?

Has BJU softened in its opposition to immorality, homosexuality, or transgenderism?

Has BJU altered its biblical stance on male headship in the home and church?

Has BJU eroded its emphasis on the substitutionary, penal atonement of Christ?

Has BJU shifted its stance on the inerrancy of Scripture, the existence of a literal hell, and the exclusivity of the Christian gospel?

The clear answer to each of these questions is a resounding no.

Pettit helped orchestrate two historic and consequential changes in 2017 that have caused significant division:

  • BJU regained its federal tax-exempt status decades after the school’s ban on interracial dating led to the loss of that status. The school admitted its first Black student in 1971 during the administration of Bob Jones Jr., the founder’s son and BJU’s second president. The school has since disavowed racism.

  • The school also earned accreditation from the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges, a regional body, after opposing accreditation throughout its history. This change makes BJU more attractive to prospective students while making it easier for alumni to pursue graduate degrees.

The people wanting to cut Pettit loose see these changes as heresies against both fundamentalism and BJU’s historic DNA.

But thousands of people have signed on to a petition defending Pettit, and hundreds have offered comments explaining their support. Many are second- or third-generation alumni who say they want to send their kids to BJU but might not do so if Pettit is let go.

David Freeman is a third-generation BJU alum who recently completed a law degree from the School of Law at Loyola University in Chicago.

“The Pettit years and the changes he brought offer a new lease on life for the university and its future, if they would have it,” said Freeman, who alerted MinistryWatch to the current conflict at BJU.

Today’s battles over fundamentalist orthodoxy are far from the first for BJU. In 1954, alumni Arlin and Beka Horton founded Pensacola Christian College to provide an alternative to BJU’s alleged slide into liberalism.

But even fundamentalists must be open to some change, said Bob Jones Jr., who served as president from 1947 to 1971 and then chancellor until his death in 1997.

“If the culture of the school or the church stays fixed and the culture of the world changes, then we become odd,” Jones said. “We become weird in the world’s eyes. I don’t think that is good.”

This article originally appeared at MinistryWatch.

Steve RabeySteve Rabey is a veteran author and journalist who has published more than 50 books and 2,000 articles about religion, spirituality, and culture. He was an instructor at Fuller and Denver seminaries and the U.S. Air Force Academy.

SHARE THIS:
  •   
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

GET EMAIL UPDATES!

Keep in touch with Julie and get updates in your inbox!

Don’t worry we won’t spam you.

More to explore
discussion

9 thoughts on “Bob Jones University Board May Oust President For Relaxing Fundamentalist Practices”

  1. This is an interesting development. I nearly attended BJU back in 2008 and am glad I never did, however, it was nice seeing the university hire someone at the helm to create some long-needed changes. The funny thing about these criticisms of Pettit’s changes (or, changes that have happened while Pettit has been President) is that the most conservative evangelicals in the SBC or PCA are left wondering what’s not God-honoring about simply being in a bluegrass band? Triple Stix, go back to retirement and your new wife and shut up.

  2. Mellisa Fernandez

    Several decades ago, when I was homeschooling my girls, I used BJU curriculum. I only used it for one semester because I found it rife with misinformation (US history, which is easy to verify or refute). When I reached out to the publisher for correct information, my emails were not answered. I simply needed help with one thing I was not able to look up through other sources because their own curriculum contradicted itself.
    I had to read the entire booklet and make sure the information my daughter was learning was correct. I made corrections where necessary. I’m not talking about nuances, but names and dates being wrong for major Civil War battles.
    Because of the lax standards w/facts, I never encouraged my girls to pursue BJU.

  3. I know Steve Pettit and he is the best thing that ever happened to BJU. They lose him and they will be decimated. The student population will drop by 50% or more. He is a scholar, biblically literate and balanced, even though he is a fundamentalist. He does not embrace the garbage of radical cultural fundamentalists.

  4. I’m curious about the date, December 1, as the end of his contract. This is the first I’ve heard of that deadline, and it’s odd to have that end in any academic contract. Now BJU is nothing if not odd, ;) so it’s possible. But the date has been June 1, 2023. Any insights you all can offer on that date? Is this a new deadline?

    1. At a special board meeting in October, the December date for a vote on his contract renewal was set, as well as the change from a simple majority to renew his contract to 2/3 must approve. That means 5 of the 16 on the board have the power to remove him.

  5. Bob Jones University’s #1 competitor is Pensacola Christian College. That school is able to charge much cheaper tuition, and is able to get students who might be priced out by BJU. They are also able to have rules like BJU used to have. Most of their students no longer come from families that keep such rules, but are willing to abide by them for the sake of the lower cost of attending the college.

    The dilemma that has created for BJU is that, not being able to compete with Pensacola on price, they have to attract students who might also consider schools like Liberty or Cedarville. There is NO WAY that can attract such students if they try to have rules like they once had.

    Just my opinion.

  6. “Which cultural changes should we embrace as we prepare for the future? ”

    None that violate God’s Law (10 Commandments and Jesus’s guidance on how to keep it), we follow God, not the other way around.

    Let culture (not God) define your faith/how you live, and when we reach our “Sodom and Gomorrah” moment, do not be surprised by the result.

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people use their full name when commenting. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.

Comments are limited to 300 words.

Leave a Reply

The Roys Report seeks to foster thoughtful and respectful dialogue. Toward that end, the site requires that people register before they begin commenting. This means no anonymous comments will be allowed. Also, any comments with profanity, name-calling, and/or a nasty tone will be deleted.
 
MOST RECENT Articles
MOST popular articles
en_USEnglish

As we work to report the truth, your support is crucial! Help us reach our Giving Tuesday goal